RiJ Vol.6 No.43
November 24, 2009
Contact Ian McDonnell at ianmcdo@apost.plala.or.jp
Contents:
¡
s
Second Test: Japan 27 d
¡
2009-10 Top League Team Profiles
s (13) Ricoh
¡
The Grubber Kick:
s IRB Ranking: 13 (70.59, 23 November 2009) New Record
High
s
Backchat:
RiJ brings the reader the results of the second test between Japan and
Canada played in
On 6 July 2009 the Japan
Rugby Football Union announced that
First Test:
Second Test:
In July 2009 the Emperor and
Empress of
Japan 27 d
Japan 27 – Tries: Go Aruga, Kensuke Hatakeyama,
Michael Leitch, Ayumu Goromaru; Conversions: Ryan Nicholas, Shaun Webb, ; Penalty: Webb d.
Date: Saturday, 21 November 2009.
Venue: Prince Chichibu Memorial Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 2:00 PM (local
Referee: Vinnie Munro (NZ).
Conditions: Fine, Still, 15°C. Firm,
fast ground.
Attendance: 10, 175.
Halftime:
Previous
Encounters
Japan 46 d
Japan 34 d
Japan 39 d
Japan 23 d
Japan 32 d
Japan 26 d
Japan 16 d
Japan 24 d
Japan 32 d
Japan 33 d
Japan 38 d
Japan 9 d
Japan (IRB rank 13, at 16 November 2009)
Pos. |
Name |
Club |
Age |
Hgt/Wgt |
Caps |
1 |
Naoki
KAWAMATA |
Sanyo |
24 |
184/118 |
5 |
2 |
Shota HORIE |
Sanyo |
23 |
180/104 |
2 |
3 |
Kensuke
HATAKEYAMA |
Suntory |
24 |
178/122 |
10 |
4 |
Hitoshi
ONO |
Toshiba |
31 |
192/105 |
37 |
5 |
Toshizumi KITAGAWA |
|
28 |
195/105 |
25 |
6 |
Michael
LEITCH |
|
21 |
189/99 |
9 |
7 |
Phil
O’REILLY |
Yokogawa |
29 |
190/105 |
11 |
8 |
Takashi KIKUTANI (c) |
|
29 |
187/100 |
28 |
9 |
Tomoki
YOSHIDA |
Toshiba |
27 |
171/78 |
20 |
10 |
Shaun
WEBB |
Coca-Cola |
27 |
180/90 |
16 |
11 |
Hirotoki ONOZAWA |
Suntory |
31 |
180/87 |
54 |
12 |
Ryan
NICHOLAS |
Suntory |
30 |
192/100 |
17 |
13 |
Alisi TUPUAILEI |
Honda |
29 |
187/116 |
2 |
14 |
Kosuke ENDO |
|
28 |
186/90 |
25 |
15 |
Go
ARUGA |
Suntory |
25 |
175/84 |
14 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
16 |
Takeshi
KIZU |
|
21 |
183/110 |
1 |
17 |
Hisateru HIRASHIMA |
|
26 |
180/115 |
10 |
18 |
Shinya
MAKABE |
Suntory |
22 |
192/110 |
1 |
19 |
Toetu’u TAUFA |
Kintetsu |
28 |
183/105 |
9 |
20 |
Yuki
YATOMI |
Yamaha |
24 |
176/83 |
13 |
21 |
James
ARLIDGE |
|
30 |
187/93 |
16 |
22 |
Ayumu GOROMARU |
Yamaha |
23 |
185/98 |
10 |
Head Coach - John Kirwan.
(33rd test as coach, for 17 wins, a draw and 15 losses.)
Subs
16 subbed 2, 34 min 2H.
17 subbed 1, 34
min 2H.
18 subbed 5, 25
min 2H.
19 subbed 7, 11
min 2H.
20 not used.
21 subbed 15, 0
min 2H.
22 subbed 14, 29
min 1H.
|
Name |
Club |
Age |
Hgt/Wgt |
Caps |
1 |
Kevin
Tkachuk |
|
33 |
180/115 |
52 |
2 |
Pat Riordan (c) |
|
30 |
185/106 |
26 |
3 |
Doug
Woolridge |
Cowichan |
23 |
184/99 |
4 |
4 |
Jebb Sinclair |
Castaway
Wanderers |
23 |
182/108 |
11 |
5 |
Tyler
Hotson |
|
24 |
196/112 |
12 |
6 |
Nanyak Dala |
Castaway
Wanderers |
25 |
178/94 |
9 |
7 |
Adam
Kleeberger |
|
25 |
195/95 |
23 |
8 |
Aaron
Carpenter |
|
26 |
183/104 |
30 |
9 |
Sean
White |
JBAA |
21 |
180/83 |
2 |
10 |
Ander
Monro |
Castaway
Wanderers |
28 |
178/88 |
19 |
11 |
Justin
Mensah-Coker |
Moseley
(Eng) |
25 |
196/107 |
20 |
12 |
Nick
Blevins |
Velox Valhallians |
20 |
188/98 |
2 |
13 |
Matt
Evans |
|
21 |
183/89 |
8 |
14 |
Ciaran Hearn |
Castaway
Wanderers |
23 |
190/100 |
10 |
15 |
James
Pritchard |
|
30 |
175/85 |
31 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
16 |
Mike
Pletch |
Velox Valhallians |
26 |
180/111 |
23 |
17 |
Dan
Pletch |
|
26 |
180/108 |
24 |
18 |
Chauncey
O’Toole |
Castaway
Wanderers |
23 |
184/80 |
4 |
19 |
Mark
MacSween |
Balmy
Beach |
23 |
190/97 |
- |
20 |
Phil
Mack |
|
24 |
170/77 |
6 |
21 |
Nathan
Hirayama |
|
21 |
183/88 |
4 |
22 |
Sean
Duke |
|
21 |
189/89 |
5 |
Head Coach: Kieran Crowley (48).
Subs
16 not used.
17 subbed 3, 22
min 2H.
18 subbed 8, 22
min 2H.
19 not used.
20 subbed 9, 17
min 2H.
21 subbed 15, 13
min 2H.
22 subbed 14, 28
min 1H.
Preview
Although there were some
bright patches for
There is not a lot of time
for Canadian head coach Kieran Crowley and his team to turn things
around as the two sides transfer from
In
Kirwan has made only one
change to the starting line-up that did the job in
For
Finally,
Wrap-up
In the ninth minute of play,
Samoan born outside centre Alisi Tupuailei used his size and strength inside the
Canadian 22 to brush off the defence and put fullback Go Aruga
into a hole. Aruga then ran in unopposed to score the
first try of the test. Inside centre Ryan Nicholas was handed the goal
kicking duties for this game after five-eighth Shaun Webb did the job in
Japan were next to score in
the twentieth minute when tight head prop Kensuke Hatakeyama
squeezed through an opening in a ruck on the Canadian
line to plant the ball across the line for his fourth test try. In the absence
of a TMO, referee Vinnie Munro consulted assistant referee Taizo Hirabayashi
before awarding the try. This time the kick was easier for Nicholas and he made
no mistakes to stretch the lead to 12-0.
A few minutes later,
Late in the half,
At halftime,
Japan maintained the pressure in the early stages of
the second half and in the eighth minute No8 and captain Takashi Kikutani found space down the short side of a ruck to then draw the defence and put blindside flanker Michael
Leitch in for the third Japanese try. Webb was in
charge of the kicking in the second half and he landed the conversion from
close to the right hand touchline to open up a 19-3 lead.
Over the final 20 minutes of the test
To the very end the Canadians pressed the Japanese try
line but were unable to break through and the game ended with the hosts winning
27-6 after scoring four tries to none.
Top League Profiles
2009-10: (13) Ricoh Black Rams
Established: Ricoh, one of the
relatively older company teams running around in Top League, were established
in 1953. The company address is listed as downtown
The golden age for Ricoh was
the early to mid 1970s when they dominated Japanese corporate rugby over this
period. However, it has been a long time between drinks and Ricoh are a long
way off the pace of the top teams in the modern era. Common to the woes of all
teams outside the top 8, they lack the pulling power for the high profile local
players coming through the university system. Their fortunes are thus on
something of a vicious cycle. Ricoh had to battle through the promotion and
relegation play-offs every year in the first 4 years of Top League and their
luck finally ran out when they finished 13th at the end of the
2007-8 season and were automatically relegated. However, Ricoh re-organised
their operations, topped the Top East 11 competition undefeated and then beat
Honda and Mazda in the Top Challenge Series to regain their place in Top League
for the 2009-10 season.
The Company: Cameras, business machines
such as photocopiers, printers, fax machines and other electronic devices.
Titles:
Top League
2008-9 (14 teams): DNP. Ricoh
played in the Top East 11 competition.
2007-8 (14 teams): 13th
on 17 points with 3 wins & 10 losses. Relegated to Top
East 11.
2006-7 (14 teams): 11th on
21 points with 4 wins & 9 losses.
2005-6 (12 teams): 11th
on 10 points with 2 wins & 9 losses.
2004-5 (12 teams): 10th
on 18 points with 4 wins & 7 losses.
2003-4 (12 teams): 9th
on 15 points with 3 wins & 8 losses.
Microsoft Cup
From 2004 to 2006 the Microsoft Cup (MC) was a
separate knock-out tournament for the top 8 finishers in TL. From 2007 the MC
has acted as the play-off finals series to determine the overall TL champion
with the top four finishers on the TL ladder progressing to the MC.
2009: DNP.
2008: DNQ as only top 4 TL teams qualified.
2007: DNQ as only top 4 TL teams qualified.
2006: DNQ as only
top 8 TL teams qualified.
2005: DNQ as only
top 8 TL teams qualified.
2004: DNQ as only
top 8 TL teams qualified.
National
Championship – twice, with back-to-back titles in 1973 and 1974.
2009 (10 teams): Qualified as the
Top Challenger. Drew with
2008 (8 teams): DNQ as only top 4
TL teams qualified.
2007 (8 teams): DNQ as only top 4
TL teams qualified.
2006 (8 teams): DNQ as only top 4
TL teams qualified.
2005 (8 teams): DNQ as only top 4
TL teams qualified.
2004 (22 teams): DNQ as only top
8 TL teams qualified.
Corporate Champions – three times (1971 (joint
champions with Shin Nitetsu Kamaishi
after final drawn 6-all) 1973 & 1974). Also runners-up
twice (1972 & 1975).
Colours: Black jersey,
shorts and socks. The second jersey is white with black flashes through the
flanks.
Style of Play: In the first 4 seasons of
Top League Ricoh struggled, finishing well down the ladder every year. Then,
they finished 13th and were relegated at the end of the 2007-8
season but to their credit they re-grouped and fought their way back into Top
League after just the one season in the Top East 11 competition. Throughout
their five years in Top League, Ricoh had a number of high profile coaches such
as Tim Lane and before him Brian Smith, though at the end of the
day there has not been the necessary continuity and stability in the coaching
ranks. After
In some ways, relegation was
the wake-up call that Ricoh had to have as they re-vamped their operations for
2008-9 and playing in the less demanding Top East league enabled the new set-up
room for trial and error. Todd Louden and his new
coaching staff worked hard to improve things at Ricoh but one of the real coups
for the club was the signing of Wallabies legend Stephen Larkham.
Larkham is far from a one man miracle worker but the
aura surrounding the man has been inspiring for all concerned at the Rams.
After being relegated Ricoh
made drastic changes to playing personnel and this continued into the 2009-10
season with 17 players leaving, while 20 new players joined the club. What they
now have is a solid core of a squad with a good balance between overseas and
local players. It still remains to be seen, but on paper at least Ricoh look
set to chalk up a number of wins while possibly giving some of the more fancied
sides a scare along the way. All-in-all, Ricoh will be aiming to be competitive
this season while ultimately trying to avoid the automatic relegation positions
and also the promotion and relegation play-off positions. If Ricoh can finish
tenth or better on the final table it will be a fantastic turn around for this
proud club.
Players to Watch: without a doubt the figure of Stephen Larkham
will be larger than life at Ricoh in the 2009-10 season. The former Wallaby who
played most of his 102 tests at five-eight is being used more at fullback under
coach Todd Louden where he
has more room to move. Larkham had last season to
settle into life in
In the forwards, veteran lock
Hiroyuki Tanuma will again lead from the front
in what is the 14th season with the club for the 36-year-old. Further, Tongan-born two metre lock Emosi
Kauhenga is now in his third year with Ricoh this
season after graduating from
In the backs, 7s specialist Yusuke
Kobuki will be looking to make a mark this year
and Ryo Kanazawa will also be hoping to carry on his form from recent
seasons from the centres. Masatoshi Mukawa and
Yoshimitsu Kawano will be fighting for
the five-eight position with the latter most likely taking the goal kicking
responsibilities. Larkham’s former Brumbies team mate
Joel Wilson also joined Ricoh last year from Kobe and his versatility in
being able to cover a number of positions will be valuable. Roy Kinikinilau linked up with Ricoh this season from IBM
and at 193cms and 110kgs he will be bound to threaten opposition defences
throughout the season. Teams opposing Ricoh this season can be excused for
seeing double as Kenichi Yokoyama joins his twin brother Shinichi
in the outside backs. The two brothers have represented
Cap holders for
There were no representatives from Ricoh in the 2009 Asian
Five Nations (A5N) tournament, or the 2009 edition of the Pacific
Nations Cup (PNC).
In the two home tests against the
There were no representatives from Ricoh in the
inaugural Asian Five Nations (A5N) tournament in 2008, or the 2008
edition of the Pacific Nations Cup (PNC).
At the 2007 Rugby World Cup
in
Hiroyuki
TANUMA 36 y/o, 42 caps at lock.
Wataru IKEDA 33
y/o, 14 caps at halfback.
(Shinichi TSUKIDA with 9 caps
at halfback retired at the end of the 2008-9 season.)
The Coach: Australian Todd Louden (39) was appointed the new head coach for the
2008-9 season and so he is in his second year this
season. Louden was an assistant coach under Ewan
McKenzie at the Waratahs over the 2007 and 2008 seasons and was also an
assistant coach at the Bulls in South Africa in 2006. Coming on board last
season too were forwards coach South African Botha Human, coach at the
Bulls from 2005-8 and technical coach NZer Lance
Hayward who was an analyst at the Waratahs from 2005-8.
Before Louden,
Toshiaki Sato was appointed head coach in April 2006 taking over from Tim
Lane and he coached the team for two seasons. Sato joined Ricoh as a player
in 1985 straight from high school and played as a centre right through till he
retired in 2001. From 2002 he coached Tokai Uni for four years before
rejoining Ricoh as backs coach. The two seasons before Sato saw non-Japanese as
head coaches. Former Springbok Peter Muller was backs coach in 2006-7,
though his services were not required after that. Muller played 33 Tests for
the Boks in the centres including RWC 99 before
moving on to play & coach with
Brian Smith was coach before
The Captain: The new captain for the
2009-10 season is halfback Wataru
Ikeda. Ikeda has 14 caps for
Before Ikeda, flanker Shoji
Ito was captain for three years but he moved to
Hooker Yoshiyuki Takizawa
is again vice-captain in the forwards this year while Yoshimitsu
Kawano is also again the vice-captain in the backs.
In addition to the captain
and vice-captains as noted above, Ricoh also have a system in place where wing Yusuke
Kobuki is club captain and lock Hiroyuki Tanuma and halfback Naotaka
Yuasa are the club vice-captains.
Losses: (17) The following is an
incomplete list of the losses at Ricoh.
Yusuke NIWA 26 y/o, prop,
181/115. Retired after 4 years with the club.
Koji NAKAMURA 28 y/o, prop,
177/100. Retired after 6 years with the club.
Shunsuke KATAOKA 29
y/o, prop, 180/115. Retired after 7 years with the club.
Reo TOMORI 33 y/o, prop,
175/98. To Sanix after 9 years with the club.
Kazunori ISOOKA 28 y/o, lock,
187/88. Retired after 6 years with the club.
Filipo LEVI (NZ) 30 y/o, lock/flanker,
196/118, 4 caps for Samoa & 2 caps for Pacific Islands, Highlanders S12/14,
Otago NPC. To Ospreys in
Satoru ENDO 37 y/o, lock,
193/100. Retired after 3 years with the club.
Shoji ITO
28 y/o, flanker, 191/95. To
Yasuharu URYU 29 y/o, centre, 176/82. To Canon
after one year with the club.
Tsutomu NISHITSUJI 30 y/o,
180/83. Retired after 7 years with the club.
Gains: (20)
Kazuya TAMURA, 33 y/o, hooker/prop, 170/100. From World (1999-2008).
Samuela MAFILEO (
Yuta ITO, 27 y/o, prop, 173/118. From Yamaha (2005-2008).
Kei SUMITA, 24 y/o, prop, 182/108. From
World (2008).
Daisuke KUWABARA, 23 y/o, prop, 180/101. From
Si-Bo WANG (
Shozo FUKUNAGA 34 y/o, lock, 190/102. From Sanyo
(1999-2008).
Hottie
LOUW (SA) 33
y/o, lock/flanker/No8, 198/115, 7 caps for Springboks, S12/14 Stormers & Bulls.
Tomohiro
ONUMA 28 y/o, lock, 191/105. From Secom (2004-2008).
Kazuhiro
SHIBATA 23 y/o, lock/flanker, 186/102. From Nihon Sports Univ.
Takeshi
MABUCHI 22 y/o, lock/flanker, 186/102. From
Hiroyuki
MORIYAMA 22 y/o, lock/No8, 184/103. From
Rocky
HAVILI (
Takeru YOSHIZAWA 22 y/o, flanker, 173/90. From
Kazuhiro
MORIYA 22 y/o, flanker/No8, 182/95. From
Takashi
KAMIO 26 y/o, halfback, 167/73. From Secom (2005-2008).
Kenichi
YOKOYAMA 23 y/o, five-eighth/wing, 180/80. From
Daniel PETERS (NZ), 24 y/o,
five-eighth/centre, 180/87. From
Akihiro
SHIGEMI 24 y/o, centre, 181/89. From IBM (2007-2008).
Roy
KINIKINILAU
(NZ) 29 y/o, centre, 193/110. From IBM (2008).
Overseas Players & Staff: (11 + 5)
Emosi
KAUHENGA (
Pieter FERREIRA (SA) 33 y/o, flanker/No8,
192/105, 3rd year, Stormers, Cats, Lions
S14.
Stephen LARKHAM (Aus), 35 y/o,
five-eighth/fullback, 189/88, 2nd year, 102 caps for Wallabies,
S12/14 Brumbies.
Joel
WILSON (Aus)
32 y/o, centre, 187/95, 2nd year,
Gerhard HUMAN (SA) 23 y/o, flanker/No8, 189/104, 2nd
year, Lions S14.
Samuela MAFILEO (
Si-Bo WANG (
Hottie
LOUW (SA) 33
y/o, lock/flanker/No8, 198/115, 1st year, 7 caps for Springboks,
S12/14 Stormers & Bulls.
Rocky
HAVILI (
Daniel
PETERS (NZ),
24 y/o, five-eighth/centre, 180/87, 1st year. From
Roy
KINIKINILAU
(NZ) 29 y/o, centre, 193/110, 1st year. From IBM
(2008).
Todd LOUDEN (Aus) 39 y/o, head coach, 2nd year.
Botha Human (SA), forwards coach, 2nd year.
Lance
Jeff WHITE, strength coach.
Stuart PAYBURY??, rehabilitation and
performance coach.
The 2009-10 Squad: (52) the list starts with
captain and vice-captains and continues through forwards and backs in order
from props to fullbacks. All family names come last.
Wataru Ikeda (c), Yoshiyuki
Takizawa (v-c forwards), Yoshimitsu Kawano (v-c
backs), Yusuke Kobuki (club captain), Hiroyuki Tanuma (club vice-captain), Naotaka
Yuasa (club vice-captain). Forwards: Kazuya Tamura, Samuela
Mafileo, Yuta Ito, Hiroki Tatenai, Hideaki Takahashi, Kei Sumita,
Yuki Mori, Yusuke Nagae, Daisuke Kuwabara,
Si-Bo Wang, Katsuya Otake, Shozo Fukunaga, Hottie Louw, Emosi Kauhenga,
Tomohiro Oinuma, Ryota Ai,
Koji Ai, Mitsuki Sakamoto, Kazuhiro Shibata, Takeshi
Mabuchi, Hiroyuki Moriyama, Pieter Ferreira, Keigo Goto, Rocky Havili, Rikiya Kawakami, Keiichiro Suenaga,
Gerhard Human, Takeru Yoshizawa
and Kazuhiro Moriya. Backs: Takashi Kamio, Yuta Goto, Kenichi Yokoyama,
Stephen Larkham, Masatoshi Mukawa,
Daniel Peters, Shota Tsuda,
Joel Wilson, Ryo Kanazawa, Akihiro Shigemi, Atsushi
Saito, Roy Kinikinilau, Shinsuke
Ikegami, Daisuke Komatsu, Fumiya Santo, Shori Hoshino
and Shinichi Yokoyama. Head Coach: Todd Louden.
The Grubber Kick
The Grubber Kick brings
the reader weekly news shorts, gossip and general happenings from the world of Rugby
in Japan.
IRB ranking on 23 November 2009 -
Backchat:
Japan
With all the international
rugby happening around the world in the busy month of November one highly
significant piece of news coming out of
In tough economic times,
Yamaha have made the corporate decision to dramatically cut back on their
commitment to rugby by not renewing the professional contracts they have with
seventeen players, including all overseas players. Thus, Yamaha are to revert
to a company employees only based team and so the ball will be in the court of
the eight contracted Japanese players such as fullback Ayumu
Goromaru and halfback Yuki Yatomi
as to whether they move on in order to pursue their professional rugby careers
or stay as salaried company workers who also happen to play a bit of rugby on
the weekends and train midweek after a long day at work.
Of course, the overseas
players and also the overseas coaching staff do not have that choice to make,
as the only option available to them will be to seek greener pastures
elsewhere. For the 2009-10 season, Yamaha have a total
of nine overseas players as well as two overseas personnel on the coaching
staff. This includes, former All Black lock or backrower
Reuben Thorne now in his second year with the club, former All Black backrower Mose Tuiali’i who only joined the team this season, former
Fijian representatives in centre Waisake Sotutu and No8 Deryck
Thomas along with New Zealanders centre Grant McQuoid
and five-eighth Male Sa’u, Korean prop Sung-Koo
Pak, South African born lock Rory Duncan and centre Joshua Levi
from Samoa. The head coach at Yamaha this season is former All Black Kevin
Schuler who has a long association with the team both as a player and as a
member of the coaching staff, while Keith Roberts also from
While this news was breaking,
Yamaha had halfback Yuki Yatomi (24) and
fullbacks Ayumu Goromaru
(23) and Kaoru Matsushita (25) in the extended
If, along with all the
overseas players, the cream of the Japanese crop at Yamaha is not there next
year then life in Top League will become unsustainable. Yamaha are
currently in dialog with the Japan Rugby Football Union (JRFU) on this
very issue but in all likelihood the probability that Yamaha will be forced to
drop out of Top League for the 2010-11 season is extremely high.
There have been other
casualties in corporate Japanese rugby since the economic woes of autumn 2008,
but none as big as Yamaha.
World started life in 1984
and played in the first four seasons of Top League finishing as high as fifth
in 2003-4. However, the wheels fell off in the 2006-7 season when they finished
a distant last and were automatically relegated. World then played out of the
Kansai based Top West competition for two seasons before calling it a day at
the end of the 2008-9 season. Players of note to leave World included
Established in 1976, IBM were
in and out of Top League but played in four of the first six seasons before
they were relegated at the end of last season (2008-9) for the second time. The
timing was not good because along with the drop the mother company felt it was
a good time to trim its commitment to rugby. IBM are playing in Top East this
season (2009-10) but after losing a host of players they are struggling mid
table. Players of note to leave IBM included captain and fullback Tadanobu Ko who moved to Kintetsu and
Secom were another team in
and out of Top League. Established in 1985, they played in three of the first
four seasons before being relegated along with World at the end of the 2006-7 season. Secom played out of Top East over the next two
seasons but just could not edge their way back into Top League. At the end of
the 2008-9 season the company went down the same path as World and IBM in not
renewing professional contracts and reverting to a strictly company based team.
Players of note to leave Secom included two metre lock Manabu Suzuki who
moved to Toshiba and former Waratahs and Brumbies backrower
Jone Tawake.
However, the case for Yamaha
is quite different to the above three former Top League sides. World, IBM and
Secom all struggled during their respective periods in Top League and the
company decisions to cut back on rugby were made when the teams were playing
outside of Top League. Yamaha, on the other hand, have been a top shelf side
over the first six seasons of Top League, and they currently sit in fifth place
on the table at the halfway mark in this, the seventh season (2009-10).
Yamaha Motor Company, Jubilo were established in 1984 and share superb facilities that include the
purpose built Yamaha Stadium with their more celebrated soccer counterparts of
the same name at Iwata city in Shizuoka prefecture. In the first six seasons of
Top League, Yamaha finished runner-up in 2004-5, while they have finished
third on two occasions and seventh three times, including the past two seasons.
After seven rounds of the 2009-10 season Yamaha are in fifth place from three
wins, two losses and two draws. They were also runner-up in the 2004 Microsoft
Cup when they lost 20-6 to Toshiba in the final. They have also reached the
semi-final stages of the National Championship three times when they
have qualified over the past six years. Yamaha have been close on a number of
occasions but they have no trophies of silverware to boast of and with their
star fading somewhat over the last couple of years the management at Yamaha
made some serious decisions in difficult economic times for the company.
This fall from grace for
Yamaha has sent out a message that the semi-professional Top League Competition
is built on very tenuous foundations indeed. The demise of World, IBM and Secom
seemed to be on the sidelines but this shock news from Yamaha comes from the
heart of the premier Japanese corporate rugby competition. A few lean years and
none of the major Top League clubs are immune from what is about to happen to
Yamaha Rugby.
One only has to scratch the
surface at a club like Sanyo to realise that should they stop being
successful the axe may fall there too. Why, even after winning their second
National Championship title in a row in the beginning of the year, the Sanyo
top brass came out in the press with the acknowledgement that they would
continue to support their rugby team while they are winning.
Reading between the lines, with Sanyo being taken over by Panasonic, in
a few years time the latter ain’t gonna’
bother with a not so competitive rugby team bearing the name of a company they
absorbed should the case arise.
NEC is another top club that is
hurting in the current economic climate. The electronics maker was mean and
lean in its recruitment of players for 2009-10 indicating the purse strings are
pretty tight and with only one win on the scoreboard they sit in the very
unfamiliar position of third from the bottom of the table after seven rounds.
Thus, it is not too fanciful to think that NEC board members might carefully
follow what is happening at Yamaha with a view to implementing similar changes
on their own turf.
Over the past year a number
of Japanese companies have been withdrawing from major world sports, including
rugby in an effort to consolidate balance sheets. For example,
Furthermore, it would only
take one or two senior executives at
One only has to extrapolate,
and top sides like Sanyo, NEC and
In turn, other Top League
sides such as Suntory, Toshiba,
This writer is of the opinion
that the JRFU has no contingency plan in place should Top League go
pear-shaped. The JRFU is not known for its vision and forward planning and so
surely this shock revelation from Yamaha has caught the
The crux of the problem lies
in the fact that senior level rugby in
RiJ has been saying it over and
over and over again, but the fundamental structures of rugby in Japan need to
be drastically reformed to take Japan into the future and realise that dream of
making this country a long-term top ten country on the world scene. Japan needs
a dynamic world class domestic competition and regionalising rugby teams,
getting local mums, dads and families to games, sharing the corporate load and
diversifying and expanding the base are crucial elements in the development and
growth of domestic rugby and in turn the fate of the national team in the lead
up to Japan hosting the 2019 Rugby World Cup. Japan were ranked 22 in
the IRB Rankings just a few short years ago but under the guidance of
head coach John Kirwan, Japan hit a record high of 13 this week (16
November 2009 rankings) after beating Canada in the first test. In concrete
terms,
The Draw
The Draw gives the
reader future dates for the diary and other great things to look forward to in
Rugby in
Sevens
The East Asia Championship is to be held in