RiJ Vol.7 No.4
January, 2010
Contact Ian McDonnell at ianmcdo@apost.plala.or.jp
Contents:
¡
47th National
Championship 2009-10: Second Round
s
s NEC
38 d Teikyo 5
¡
Final Top League Promotion &
Relegation
s Ricoh
59 d Mazda 12
s Kintetsu 28 d Yokogawa 8
¡
IRB Sevens
¡
Odds & Sods:
s IRB Ranking: 13 (70.59, 25 January 2010)
s Kiyomiya resigns at Suntory;
Andre Pretorius to play in
s The Think-tank: The Origins Series
¡
Looking Ahead:
s
The 47th
National Championship 2009-2010
The National Championship
(NC) had an 8-team format for three years prior to 2009, but for 2009 the
number of teams was increased to ten with the inclusion of two extra Top League
sides. For 2010, the NC involves six Top League sides, the two top university
teams, the winner of the Top Challenge Series and the Top Club team. The first
round of the NC kicked off on Sunday, 7 February 2010.
The top four Top League
finishers gained automatic qualification to the NC, that
is, Sanyo (first on 59 points), Suntory (second on 58 points), Toshiba
(third on 52 points and
For 2010 the Wildcard
Tournament was introduced for the Top League sides that finished fifth to
tenth on the final table. These six sides were:
The two
universities that participated in the 46th National University
Championship final gained admission to the NC.
NTT
Communications Shining Arcs (Top East), won the Top Challenge One
series and gained automatic entry to the NC as the Top Challenger.
Rokko Fighting Bull won the 17th
National Club Championship to determine the Top Club participant in the NC.
Second Round
Date: Sunday, 14 February 2010.
Venue: Prince Chichibu Memorial
Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 12:00.
Preview
NTT Communications Shining
Arcs have
their first real taste of things to come in Top League next season when they
confront Toyota Verblitz in the second round
of the National Championship.
NTT went through the rounds
of Top East undefeated this season and then won both their games in the Top
Challenge series to win promotion to Top League for the 2010-11 season as well as qualify for the National Championship as
the Top Challenger. In the first round of the Championship last Sunday, NTT
snuck past
The winner of this match then
goes on to play Toshiba Brave Lupus in the semi-finals.
Wrap-up
NTT Communications Shining
Arcs had a prelude of what to expect in Top League next season when they went
down to Toyota Verblitz 50-17 in the second round of
the National Championship in
NEC
Green Rockets (Wildcard) 38 d
Date: Sunday, 14 February 2010.
Venue: Prince Chichibu Memorial
Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 14:00.
Preview
NEC had an
horrendous start to their season losing nine of their first ten games but
finished with three wins in their last three games to claim the final place in
the Wildcard Tournament. NEC then went from strength to strength beating
Sanix and then Kubota in that tournament to take one
of the two Top League Wildcard entry spots in the National Championship.
All the recent hard work paid
off handsomely for NEC in the first round of the National Championship last
weekend when they held the highly fancied Suntory Sungoliath
to at 10-all draw. The luck of the gods was then with game captain Nili Latu as he
pulled out the winning ballot to continue the remarkable turnaround for the
Rockets over the latter stages of the season.
The Green Rockets have now won
their last six games and they will be aiming to make it seven in a row with a
good win over Teikyo to progress to a semi-final
showdown with Sanyo Wild Knights.
On the other hand, Teikyo qualified for the National Championship as the top
university after they beat Tokai 14-13 in the university final at the National
Stadium in
Wrap-up
NEC Green Rockets continued
on their winning way when they overcame a spirited
First Round
NEC Green Rockets (Top League Wildcard) 10 drew with Suntory
Sungoliath (Top League 2) 10
Date: Sunday, 7 February 2010.
Venue: Kintetsu
Hanazono Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 14:00.
Date: Sunday, 7 February 2010.
Venue: Prince Chichibu Memorial
Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 14:00.
NTT Communications Shining Arcs (Top Challenger) 11 d
Date: Sunday, 7 February 2010.
Venue: Prince Chichibu Memorial
Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 12:00.
Date: Sunday, 7 February 2010.
Venue: Kintetsu
Hanazono Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 12:00.
Semi-finals
Saturday, 20 February 2010.
Sanyo Wild Knights (Top League Play-off
finalist) v NEC (Wildcard).
Toshiba Brave Lupus (Top League Play-off
finalist) v
Final
Sunday, 28 February 2010.
Chichibu.
Final Top League Promotion & Relegation Matches
Ricoh & Kintetsu Retain their Places in TL
for 2010-11
Ricoh
Black Rams (Top League 12) 59 d Mazda Zoomers (third in Top Challenge 1) 12.
Date: Saturday, 13
February 2010.
Venue: Prince Chichibu
Memorial Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 14:00.
The three sides
that finished first in their respective regional leagues, that is Top East, Top West and Top Kyushu, took part in the
2009-10 Top Challenge One series playing each other once. NTT Communications
Shining Arcs and Toyota Jido Shokki finished first and second respectively and
gained automatic promotion to Top League for the 2010-11 season. The Mazda Zoomers finished third in Top Challenge One and they
have one last chance in the final Promotion and Relegation play-off with the
team that finished twelfth in Top League in 2009-10, that is, Ricoh Black
Rams.
Wrap-up
Ricoh Black Rams confirmed
their place in Top League for the 2010-11 season with
an emphatic 59-12 win over Mazda Zoomers in
Kintetsu Liners (Top League 11) 28 d Yokogawa
Musashino Atlastars
(winner of Top Challenge 2) 8.
Date: Saturday, 13
February 2010.
Venue: Kintetsu Hanazono Rugby Ground,
Kick-off: 13:00.
The three sides
that finished in second position in their respective regional leagues took part
in Top Challenge Two. These three sides played each other once with the top
side in Yokogawa Musashino Atlastars
(Top East), winning the right to take on Kintetsu
Liners, the team that finished eleventh in Top League in 2009-10, for a
place in Top League for next season.
Wrap-up
Five-eighth Yasumasa Shigemitsu led the Kintetsu Liners to victory over Yokogawa Musashino Atlastars with two
tries and four conversions to come away with eighteen points to his name from
the 28-8 win. Playing on their home ground was a bonus for the Liners as they
opened up a 21-3 lead by the end of the first half. Halfback Chul-Won Kim and wing Yohei
Shinomiya were the other try scorers for Kintetsu while wing Makoto Kasahara
was the lone try scorer for Yokogawa.
Japan
(Confirmed 14 February 2010)
This will be the eighth season of Top League. The
numbers in brackets indicate seasons in Top League.
1 |
Toshiba
Brave Lupus (8) |
2 |
Sanyo
Wild Knights (8) |
3 |
Suntory
Sungoliath (8) |
4 |
|
5 |
|
6 |
Kubota
Spears (8) |
7 |
|
8 |
Coca-Cola
Red Sparks (5) |
9 |
Yamaha
Jubilo (8) |
10 |
NEC
Green Rockets (8) |
11 |
Kintetsu
Liners (5) |
12 |
Ricoh
Black Rams (7) |
13 |
NTT
Communications (1) |
14 |
|
Kyuden Voltex and Honda Heat were
automatically relegated at the completion of the 2009-10 season
for finishing 13th and 14th.
NTT Communications Shining
Arcs and Toyota
Jido Shokki won
promotion through the Top Challenge series.
Kintetsu Liners and Ricoh Black Rams
retained their places in Top League when they won their respective promotion
and relegation play-offs.
What a Complete and Utter
Waste of Time!
The last word on promotion
and relegation play-offs for another season is: Why?
In the seven year history of
Top League, the bottom two teams have been automatically relegated and the two
best regional teams playing through the Top Challenge Series promoted to take
their places. That much makes some sense. However, what does not make any sense
at all is the fact that the two sides that finish above the bottom two place
getters then have to go through a one-off play-off against the also rans of the
Top Challenge Series to retain their places in Top League for the following
season.
There is a lot working
against this concept and as far as RiJ is concerned
absolutely nothing working for it. Over the seven years of Top League not one
of the challengers have ever won their way into Top
League via this method. This year, Ricoh and Kintetsu
played their last game on 9 January and then had to hang around for FIVE weeks
to play a game that they were always going to win anyway. Thank you for coming,
but Mazda had the same chance of beating Ricoh as a snowflake has of surviving
in hell and even though Yokogawa on paper at least should have fronted up
against Kintetsu it never happened. The games are not
shown on J Sports as understandably they could not be bothered and it seems the
fans feel the same way with attendances barely breaking into four figures.
There is as much interest in these games as there is in going to the dentist
for root canal treatment. Doesn’t this suggest something? Hello?
What do we want?
Dump the Top League promotion
and relegation play-offs!
When do we want it?
Seven years ago!
IRB Sevens
13-14 February
2010
The
|
Name |
Club |
Age |
Hgt. |
Wgt. |
1 |
Kenji SHOMEN |
|
26 |
175 |
84 |
2 |
Masahiro TSUIKI |
Coca-Cola |
26 |
176 |
88 |
3 |
Kaoru MATSUSHITA |
Yamaha |
26 |
185 |
86 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
5 |
Hiraku TOMOIGAWA |
NTT Communications |
25 |
168 |
68 |
6 |
Yusaku KAWAZURU |
Coca-Cola |
24 |
188 |
95 |
7 |
Yuki SUEMATSU |
Honda |
24 |
183 |
89 |
8 |
Lepuha LATUILA |
Daito Bunka Univ. |
25 |
187 |
103 |
9 |
Takashi TOYOMAE |
|
22 |
177 |
80 |
10 |
Daisuke NATSUI |
Kanto Gakuin Uni. |
21 |
188 |
88 |
11 |
Tomohiro SHOKAI |
Doshisha Uni. |
20 |
186 |
82 |
12 |
Yoshiaki TSURUGASAKI |
Tokai Uni. |
20 |
185 |
97 |
Japan Sevens Staff
Wataru Murata (head coach, Yamaha),
Kensuke Iwabuchi (coach, JRFU),
Masahiro Furudate (trainer, Reniart).
Pools
Pool A:
Pool B:
Pool C:
Pool D:
Odds & Sods
Odds & Sods brings the
reader weekly news shorts, gossip and general happenings from the world of Rugby
in Japan.
News in
IRB ranking on 8 February 2010 -
Suntory coach Katsuyuki
Kiyomiya has resigned as head coach after four
years in the job after the less than adequate 10-all draw with NEC in the
second round of the National Championship last weekend. Suntory lost when the
captains had to draw straws to determine the winner. It seems a bit odd that Kiyomiya would use this as a reason to jump but waiting in
the wings is none other than present general manager Eddie Jones. With
Jones fulltime this season at Suntory after being an adviser while being
involved with Saracens, the Reds and South Africa in the recent past, RiJ felt the coaches’ box must have been bulging at the
seams with these two egos. After a highly successful career as a player and
coach at both
Rugby scribe Rich Freeman has the bite on a rumour
that Andre Pretorius in
Rich also states that lock Albert van den Berg is to join lower division side Canon. It seems the number of
South Africans venturing to
The Think-tank:
The Origin Series
There is a pot of gold
sitting under the noses of the JRFU, but unfortunately it is totally
overlooked. The annual Tri-Regions tournament comes and goes and if only it was
treated with a bit more respect the series could be a real cracker, along the
lines of the ‘State of
The Japan Rugby Football
Union (JRFU) is the overall administrator of rugby in
This is just one of many options
that RiJ has suggested over the years, but it makes
such commonsense to expand on what is already there to give provincial
representative rugby some real teeth. Let’s make an “Origin Series” to create a
much needed tier of rugby between the university and company leagues and the
national team!
Below is a very simple and
incomplete list of some of the more prominent players running around in
Japanese rugby broken up into place of origin falling into Kanto, Kansai or
The Origin Series should be
used as a selection process for the national team as well as fostering a
sense of tribalism in regional pride. In this respect, all players
should be eligible for national selection. RiJ has
plonked eligible overseas players into regions their teams are located, or in
the odd case, like Michael Leitch, where that player
went to high school in
An Origin Series featuring
the best players in
There are also a lot of
variations that could be considered. Perhaps each region could run two sides,
one being the stronger A side and the
other the B side for developing players. Further, an U20 side or
similar age grade team could be added to create a highly competitive
tournament for younger university students that do not see much game time in
the regular season as well as high school students with the potential to mix it
at a higher level. Universities, high schools and also U18s already play their
respective East v West series without much fanfare so it is not all that
difficult to expand that to include
With only three regions, the
Origin Series would ideally have to be played home and away to give each
side at least four games. A third round too is not out of the question with the
opposition alternating each year. Given a four game home and away scenario,
this would create a perfect selection process for the national side with the Asian
Five Nations and the Pacific Nations Cup now played annually over
the late April to early July window. The regular season could be easily
compressed and the National Championship done away with leaving five or six
weeks over March and April for the Origin Series.
This simple Tri-Regions
Origin Series would be the easiest to implement as the basic series already takes
place and it would also be the most cost effective. Such a series with all the
stars of Japanese rugby spread over three regional sides would also be a far
more attractive product to sell to the media. The series would be more
of a true highlight of the domestic season as the National Championship
just does not grab the public and the media in the way such a tournament
should. The NC is too predictable and lop-sided with the universities, club
sides and lower division sides way out of their depth
against the best Top League teams leaving the semi-finals and final to be more
or less a repeat of the Top League Play-offs.
Taking a long-tem view, there
is the scope to further expand the Origin Series to better reflect the full
extent of
This longer tournament would
allow for combinations and patterns to better develop within the teams with
each side now getting four home and four away games, an added bonus for fans
and the media. The window is already there over February, March and April
so there would not need to be any significant adjustments to the university and
Top League seasons.
Another option RiJ has proposed recently is to introduce a second round of
Top League to expand the season, however, the
introduction of a National Origin Series may require Top League to stay at one
round. On the other hand though, a second round of Top League could still be
implemented creating a separate tournament for Top League sides minus their
star players. This additional round of Top League would allow fringe players
the chance for more game time as many often go through the season with next to
no time on the field. A Satellite League already exists in Top League,
but not all the teams are fully committed to it, so this could be a way of
formalising a second level of Top League. This less formal and more flexible
structure could also allow teams to develop home grounds as grounds like
Chichibu, Hanazono, Level 5, the Homes Stadium in
It’s just a thought.
Kanto
1.
Naoki Kawamata, loosehead prop, Sanyo, Seichi Fukaya,
2.
Jungo Kikawa, loosehead
prop, Sanyo, Fukaya HS, Saitama.
3.
Tomohiro Kubo, loosehead prop, Toshiba, Nakashibetsu
HS,
4.
Yusuke Aoki, hooker, Suntory, Kugayama,
5.
Yoshimitsu Yasue, hooker,
6.
Tateo Kanai, hooker, Suntory, Ota HS, Gunma.
7.
Yuta Inose, hooker, NEC, Joso Gakuin HS,
8.
Taku Inokuchi, hooker, Toshiba,
Keio Gijuku HS,
9.
Kensuke Hatakeyama, tighthead prop, Suntory,
Sendai Ikuei HS, Miyagi.
10.
Tomokazu Soma, tighthead prop, Sanyo, Tokyo HS,
Kanagawa.
11.
Hitoshi Ono, lock, Toshiba, xxxx HS,
12.
Koji Shinozuka, lock, Suntory, Saitama Fukaya, Saitama.
13.
Shinya Makabe, lock, Suntory, Sendai Technical
HS, Miyagi.
14.
Taira Sato, lock, NEC, Akita Chuo HS,
15.
Eiri Nakada, lock, Waseda, Seikei HS,
16.
Ryota Asano, flanker, NEC, Honjo
HS,
17.
Itaru Taniguchi, flanker/No.8,
18.
Phil O’Reilly, flanker, Yokogawa.
19.
Michael Leitch, flanker,
20.
Sione Vatuvei, flanker, Sanyo.
21.
Koliniasi Ryu
Holani, No.8, Sanyo, Saitama Fukaya.
22.
Shuetsu Narita, halfback, Suntory, Akita Technical HS,
23.
Shota Goto, halfback,
24.
Naoya Nomura, five-eighth, Suntory, Saitama Fukaya, Saitama.
25.
Eiji Ando, five-eighth, NEC, Kumagaya
Technical, Saitama.
26.
Seiichi Shimomura, centre, Sanyo, Tokyo Nodaini
HS, Gunma.
27.
Bryce Robins, centre, NEC.
28.
Ryan Nicholas, centre, Suntory.
29.
Katoni Otukolo, centre, Kubota, Saitama Fukaya.
30.
Kosuke Endo, wing,
31.
Kenichi Yokoyama, wing, Ricoh, Yamagata Chuo HS, Yamagata.
32.
Shinichi Yokoyama, wing, Ricoh, Yamagata Chuo HS, Yamagata.
33.
Hiroki Yoshida, fullback, Toshiba, Tokyo Nodaini
HS,
34.
Tadanobu Ko, fullback, Kintetsu, Toin Gakuen, xxxx.
Kansai
1.
Takahiro Sugiura, loosehead prop, Sanix, xxxx HS, Aichi.
2.
Yuji Matsubara, hooker,
3.
Mitsugu Yamamoto, hooker, Sanyo, Nitta HS,
4.
Shota Horie, hooker, Sanyo,
Shimamoto? HS,
5.
Takeshi Kizu, hooker,
6.
Hiroshi Yamashita, tighthead prop,
7.
Shinsuke Nakamura, tighthead prop, Nihon Univ, Hotoku Gakuen, Hyogo.
8.
Yosuke Ikegaya, tighthead prop, Suntory, Sotoku HS,
9.
Toshizumi Kitagawa, lock,
10.
Yuji Kitagawa, lock, Sanyo, Osaka Toin HS,
11.
Tomoaki Taniguchi, lock,
12.
Luke Thompson, lock, Kintetsu.
13.
Daniel Quate, lock,
14.
Takashi Kikutani, flanker,
15.
Takamichi Sasaki, flanker/No.8, Suntory, Keiko Gakuen HS,
16.
Masato Toyoda, No.8, Toshiba, Tokai Gyosei HS,
17.
Hajime Kiso, No.8, Yamaha,
18.
Toetu’u Taufa, No.8, Kintetsu.
19.
Tomoki Yoshida, halfback, Toshiba, Tokai Gyosei
HS,
20.
Yuki Yatomi, halfback, Yamaha, Kyoto Seisho HS,
21.
Fumiaki Tanaka, halfback, Sanyo, Fushimi Technical HS,
22.
Chul-Won Kim, halfback, Kintetsu,
Chomei,
23.
Kenji Shomen, five-eighth,
24.
Kyohei Morita, five-eighth,
25.
Shotaro Onishi, five-eighth, Kintetsu, Keiko Gakuen,
26.
Kosei Ono, five-eighth, Sanix, Canterbury Boys’,
Aichi.
27.
Yasumasa Shigemitsu, five-eighth, Kintetsu,
Fushimi Technical HS,
28.
Yoshimitsu Kawano, five-eighth, Ricoh, Hikawa
HS, Yamanashi.
29.
Ryohei Yamanaka, five-eighth, Waseda,
Tokai Gyosei HS,
30.
Hirotoki Onozawa, wing,
Suntory, Shizuoka Seiko Gakuen HS,
31.
Yuta Imamura, centre,
32.
Atsushi Moriya, centre, Honda, Kyoto Hanazono HS,
33.
Alisi Tupuailei, centre, Honda.
34.
Tomoki Kitagawa, wing, Sanyo, Higashi Yama HS,
35.
Daisuke Ohata, wing,
36.
Toshiaki Hirose, wing, Toshiba, Kitano HS,
37.
Takeshi Miyake, wing, Sanyo, Fushimi Technical,
38.
Ryo Kanazawa, wing, Ricoh, Osaka Kodai HS,
39.
Kaoru Matsushita, fullback, Yamaha, Hotoku Gakuen HS, Hyogo.
40.
Go Aruga, fullback, Suntory, Hikawa
HS, Yamanashi.
41.
Tatsuya Kusumi, fullback,
1.
Hisateru Hirashima, loosehead
prop,
2.
Akira Ozaki, loosehead prop, Suntory, Nagasaki Nanzan
HS,
3.
Ryuhei Arita, hooker, Waseda, Higashi Fukuoka,
4.
Tatsukichi Nishiura, tighthead prop, Coca-Cola, xxxx HS,
5.
Ryo Yamamura, tighthead prop, Yamaha, Saga Technical HS, xxxx.
6.
Takanori Kumagae, lock, NEC,
Higashi Fukuoka,
7.
Yoshitaka Nakayama, flanker,
8.
Tomoaki Nakai, flanker,
Toshiba, Kumamoto Technical HS,
9.
Hare Makiri, flanker, Sanix.
10.
Taro Kenjo, flanker, NEC, Tsukushi
HS,
11.
Juntaro Takemoto,
flanker/No.8, Suntory, Nagasaki Kita HS,
12.
Masakazu Toyota, No.8, Coca-Cola, Higashi Fukuoka,
13.
Takuro Miuchi, No.8, NEC, Yawata HS,
14.
Tatsuhiko Otao, five-eighth,
Yamaha, Saga Technical HS, Saga.
15.
Masakazu Irie, five-eighth, Sanyo, Yawata Chuo,
16.
Shaun Webb, five-eighth, Coca-Cola.
17.
Koji Taira, Suntory, centre, Suntory, Nagasaki Nanzan HS, Saga.
18.
Tomohiro Semba, centre, Toshiba, Yawata Technical HS,
19.
Brendan Neilson, centre, Coca-Cola.
20.
Shinji Nakazono, wing, Yamaha, Saga Technical,
Saga.
21.
Akihito Yamada, wing, Honda, Kokura HS,
22.
Ayumu Goromaru, fullback,
Yamaha, Saga Technical HS,
23.
Daisuke Haradome, fullback, Coca-Cola, Kagoshima
Technical HS,
24.
Goshi Tachikawa, fullback,
Toshiba, Saga Technical HS, Saga.
25.
Yasunori Nagatomo, wing,
Suntory, Takanabe HS,
Looking Ahead
Looking Ahead gives the
reader future dates for the diary and other great things to look forward to in
Rugby in
13-28 March 2010.
Details of the
four match tour soon.
2010 IRB HSBC
Asian Five Nations
The 2010 A5N also doubles as
the final Asian qualification round for the 2011 RWC in
Saturday, 1 May 2010,
kick-off 14:00,
Saturday, 8 May 2010,
kick-off 14:00,
Saturday, 15 May 2010,
kick-off 16:00,
Saturday, 22 May 2010,
kick-off 14:00,
The 11th Sanix World
This annual high school
tournament is again set for the Golden Week period from 27 April to 6 May at
the Global Arena in Munakata in
Overseas Schools:
Japanese Schools:
IRB Junior World
18-30 May
2010,
Details
soon. In the eight team Under 20 tournament,
2010 IRB Pacific Nations Cup
June-July 2010.
Details
soon.